|
11/22/2008
|
 |
Long Term Review
How did the Banshee Scream hold up?
Trevor Hansen with Eamonn Duignan - nsmb freeride team members
Frame,
Seatpost, fr derailleur etc.
Complete Bike Journeyman package
Complete Bike Gucci package
|
$1899
CDN $1199 US
$3199 CDN $1999 US
$4299 CDN $2699 US
|
The Banshee Scream received an initial impressions mini-review
on NSMB in July, and after half a dozen rides the bike tests were positive.
However, a more in-depth analysis in a variety of conditions, tweaking the various
adjustments available on the bike, was necessary in order to complete the review.

Shaken not stirred.
Eamonn and I did the majority of testing over the summer, with
some help from our buddies Angus and Brent, who bought their Scream frames from
On Top Bike Shop after trying our
test bikes.
The Scream was designed by Syncros originator Pippin Osborne
as a private contract for Bow Cycles in Calgary. The Bow folks wanted a beefy
freeride bike that was reasonably priced and guaranteed to last. The prototypes
turned out so well that Pippin got some investors together and started mass
producing Banshees. The bike is as solid as a tank, probably the most durable
bike on the market. What’s surprising is that despite its hefty build
and heavy frame (13 pounds) the Banshee is nimble and responsive on the trail.

Rider: Trevor Hansen. Photo: Noel
Hendrickson
The sad reality of our sport is that all bikes can break. However,
if enough precautions are taken by the manufacturer, the rate of failure can
be reduced. The fact that Banshee has a 10-year warranty shows the manufacturer’s
confidence in the materials, design and setup
| Materials
The materials on this bike focus on thickness and strength. The head tube
is 14mm thick and cold forged into one piece. The chainstays are made
with an internal rib for extra reinforcement, the main tubes are made
from the thickest Easton RAD tubing available and the rocker arm is twice
as thick as a Kona rocker arm and made from 7075 aluminum. The arm pivot
bearings are skateboard bearings that are easy and inexpensive to replace,
as are the GM automatic transmission bearings used for the bottom pivot.
Of the four frames tested, none needed any bearing work after a full summer
of heavy riding.
|

Banshee Tubes in cross section |
| The welds on these bikes
are bomber. Banshee reinforced the head tube and the seatpost/toptube
weld with a plate weld to distribute stress. The plate is only welded
on the sides and not on the end where stress can be amplified. Pippin’s
engineering background shows through in details like these.
|

The beginning of a Scream bottom bracket shell |
| Design
Pippin’s design uses a rocker arm similar to the Kona Stab and Stinky
5 and 6. The key difference is that you can change the travel to 6”,7”
or 8”. Each of the settings were tested at the start of the summer
but all four test riders settled on the 8” mode for the rest of
the test period. The lower travel setting works well for climbing and
dirt jumping.
|

Choose between 6, 7 and 8 inches of travel |
The adjustment Eamonn and I fiddled around with most was the
wheelbase. Mini bolts in the horizontal dropouts can be adjusted to set your
wheelbase tight or long. The tight base slows the rebound and gives a rising
rate more suitable for big hits and tight turns - perfect for the Shore. The
longer wheelbase setting, which is further back on the horizontal dropouts,
gives a more linear rising rate. This increases rebound for smaller hits, thereby
serving up a smoother ride over bumps at high speed. You can either use a quick
release to clamp your wheel in or use a bolt-on axle setup. This bolt kit and
the axle should be made available to you - by the dealer - for no extra charge.There
are other goodies as well like a telescoping seatpost, front derailleur and
useful spare parts. Click here
to see what comes in a complete
frame kit. Pippin assures us dealers shouldn't be charging you anything
extra for these.

Eamonn Duignan ~ Rosehill road gap.
The frame can take a 24” or 26” wheel. The 24”
gives a raked out feel to the bike and when it's set on the shorter wheelbase
setting it offers excellent tight cornering and tracking. The 26” wheel
is better suited to a longer wheelbase setting making it the best choice for
downhillers. The 26” wheel will also roll over obstacles more easily.
Eamonn and I rode the 24” whenever we rode the Shore and we both switched
to the 26” for downhilling in Whistler, but changing wheels and cassettes
got to be too much hassle so we both stuck with the 24” for the rest of
the summer. The 24” isn’t quite as smooth over the small bumps but
it still works well downhilling. Brent Upson has been riding his Scream with
a 26” set on the short wheelbase all summer and he loves the bigger wheel
in all conditions.
The Setup
The complete Scream bikes come in a Gucci
or Journeyman
package with the big difference being the up front: Boxxers for Gucci and Psylos
for Journeyman. I am a Boxxer lover so I was happy to receive a pair of 2003
Team Boxxers to test - thanks to Jed from RockShox.
The '03 Team Boxxer was sweet for the first 5 or 6 rides. The
rebound and low/high speed compression adjustments made it easy to tune, but
it didn’t come with a big enough drop crown so it could not be set up
with a full 7”. The springs were not heavy enough to keep me from hitting
bottom. As a result the bottom out bumper failed. As this is being written Rockshox
is sending a new bumper and some heavy springs. These forks will be put through
some serious testing this fall with a review to follow.

Eamonn riding Rosehill
The Ride
Having exposed the Scream to the big hits, skinnies, steeps and flow of Williams
Lake, Kamloops, Kelowna, Whistler, Squamish, Pemberton, Seattle, and of course
the Shore, Eamonn and I both feel the Banshee Scream provides all the elements
necessary for hardcore freeriding: it takes the punishing landings, tracks through
bermed and flat corners smoothly and it has a stiff rear triangle for log rides.
On top of that the pivot design allows easy climbing on steep single track,
logs and rocks and the adjustable wheelbase provides adaptability for different
terrain and riding styles. Most important for all four of the test riders was
the strength of the frame; this is a welcome feature considering how many frames
the four of us have broken. (Too many to count - Ed.)
The Future
For 2003 Banshee is planning to offer fork options like: Manitou Dorados, Marzocchi
Monsters, Supers and Junior Ts as well as RockShox Boxxers. In the rear you’ll
be able to choose from Fox RC, Fifth Element, Romic and Risse. These options
will be available this January. Some shops, including On Top in North Van are
already offering fork options on their Screams.
Trevor Hansen with Eamonn Duignan
Spec
Gucci:
Journeyman:
|
4.5 
3.5  |
| Ride: |
5.0  |
| Price: |
4.5
 |
| Overall: |
4.5
 |
|
|
| Pros: |
Cons: |
- Frame strengths (10 yr
warr.)
- Adjustable wheelbase (versatility!)
- Nimble and responsive feel
- Big bike that rides like a smaller freerider |
- It's a heavyweight (13
pounds)
- Hassle to change to and from 26" and 24" wheels |
Check out the new Banshee site for
dealers and distributors
as well as some sweet eye candy.
Tested by ~ Trevor Hansen with Eamonn Duignan - nsmb freeride
team members
|