DSC07401-denizmerdano 45nrth ragnarok boot
Review

45NRTH Ragnarok BOA Boots

Photos Deniz Merdano - Header image Stan Goetz
Reading time

Never judge a book by its cover. But the foul weather boots from the Midwestern company 45NRTH challenge that notion with both the name and looks. The Ragnarök boot (Ragnarok from here on for google) is their transition season footwear designed to ease your way into the frozen depths of hell that is called winter in the mid-western U.S. Naming footwear after a series of battles between gods and evil, that will eventually settle a new world order, is a bold move, but these are not 45RTH's warmest winter boots.

The premise is that, before the temperatures dip way below freezing levels, there will be days of cold, rain, snow and combinations thereof, that will challenge your footwear. The Ragnarok is designed to fill the gap and transition you into deep freeze seamlessly. What if the temperatures don't dip below freezing all that often if at all and all you get is wet wet and wet winter? Could the Ragnarok BOA be the ideal Pacific North Wet winter boot?

DSC07384-denizmerdano 45nrth ragnarok boot

45NRTH Ragnarok BOA in size 42

The littlest brother of a five-boot family, the Ragnarok is built around the latest version of BOA's Li2 fit system. The Li2 from BOA is the lightest and the slimmest profile option from the the company's vast array of products. While not the most robust choice, the decision to go with the Li2 on the Ragnarok was most likely to position the boot with performance-oriented riders who are after better protection from the elements in their winter training boots. Does the Ragnarok make sense for high performance? I have been trying to find that out during the last couple of weeks of unfavorable weather.

The 597g (actual with cleats) size 42 boot, while not feather weight, is not far off most of the Enduro/DH positioned shoes on the market. The Leatt 4.0 Clip comes in at 550gr and the Crankbrothers Mallet DH at 482gr and the older Shimano MW5 at 450grams. If we consider all the material that needs to be layered in the boot's construction to keep feet warm and dry, the numbers on the scale do not seem outrageous.

DSC07393-denizmerdano 45nrth ragnarok boot

Li2 BOA system is found on high end performance road and mtb shoes

The construction of the Ragnarok BOA is designed to work comfortably down to -4c (25F). For people hoping to put wide tires on the white stuff, this is probably borderline too casual, but for us Sea-to-Sky folk, this promises a great deal of winter riding comfort. These boots are made for walking and they do that well on all the slippery stuff thanks to the ANTI-SLIP MICROGLASS RUBBER that is designed to generate tiny little spikes protruding from the rubber for traction on the greasiest logs and rocks. The boots are stiff, with all the extra rubber underneath and all the layers that come along with making sure there is a thermal barrier between the feet and the pedal. When I turned them over to install my Time cleats, I was greeted with a note reminding me that a shim is required to use Time, Crankbrothers and Look cleats if I wanted to retain the warranty. Thankfully I had some shims lying around from some Leatt shoes. I think it would be wise for 45NRTH to supply the required shims with the boots if there is a potential for sole failure without them.

Slipping into the size 42 boots for the first time, I was a little worried I requested a size too small. The BOA Li2 system provides two directions of adjustment for the user. Turn clockwise to tighten and counterclockwise to loosen. For a full release, and entering and exiting the boots, you can pull on the BOA to fully release the system. You can then pull on the neoprene cuff to create enough slack to slip into this heavy-duty feeling footwear. On the initial test fit, I was wearing thicker Gore wool socks that I generally associate with winter riding. If I put this warm layer against my feet, most shoes become winter-ready. But the socks were a little too thick to in the Ragnarok BOAs. Into the sock drawer I dove to find some thinner merino Mons Royale Socks. Once in the boots, I was greeted with a roomy toe box and a true-to-size fit for a size 42 shoe. With my big toe millimetres from the toe piece, I dialed in the BOA Li2 that loops through seven holes and two flaps to adjust. After an initial tighten and walk about, I re-tightened the BOA to take up the slack that occurred once the string settled in.

DSC07390-denizmerdano 45nrth ragnarok boot

Time cleats will require shims to avoid warranty issues.

DSC07392-denizmerdano 45nrth ragnarok boot

Aggressive tread pattern with lots of siping for grip.

With the TIme cleats installed on the rearward cleat nut and the position somewhere near the arch of the foot, I quickly realized that I needed to raise my saddle to make up for the thicker sole and a further forward than normal cleat position. Once the adjustment was made, the pedaling position felt neutral and the stiff sole provided a great platform to push off. There were no entry or exit obstacles while clipping in and out and I was confident I could clip out in a hurry in slippery conditions.

Snow riding can be super fun if all the stars line up and the texture is right. We didn't get that kind of cold dry snow for our first couple of dumps and riding in heavy wet snow is an exercise in trail salsa-dancing to balance from the hips. Clipping out to dab or even scoot on the slow rolling, sideways slipping ground is frequent. While this can be fun in a unique way, if your shoes are letting in cold and melting snow water, the ride can quickly turn into a race to the bottom to get into warm before the digits fall off.

DSC07427-denizmerdano 45nrth ragnarok boot

Not ideal riding conditions but when the trail builder is holding the camera, you just drop in.

The 45NRTH Ragnarok kept all the elements out on the slushy rides it embarked in for the past couple of weeks. Paired with my gross weather-favourite TLD Resist pants that wrap over the neoprene cuffs, not a single drop of water made its way into the boot from the top or the bottom. I've never I experienced such comfort in the most challenging conditions so I threw caution to the wind, crossing streams or walking and splashing through puddles on my way. While my feet were not overly warm in the freezing point temperatures, It was comfortable enough to play for hours while staying dry.

When my riding group decided to call it due to cold and wet toes in their "winter" gear, I was happy to keep playing for a few more hours. Walking through creeks on purpose became a game and traction the aggressive soles provided was lovely to have.

If I had to criticize one thing, it would be the cleat spacer I had to use with my Time pedals. The extra height causes a slightly vague feeling on the pedals when things get fast and rough. The feeling of bouncing on the pedal becomes a bit obvious and it can also feel like you are about to unclip even though you are perfectly secure.

As you can see in the photographs, while I did not use brand new cleats, the ones I pulled off my Shimano MW5s were quite fresh apart from the rusty bolts that unscrewed rather easily thanks to remembering to coat them in grease on installation. Never skip this step, especially on footwear that frequently sees water and salt.

DSC07432-denizmerdano 45nrth ragnarok boot

Dry, warm, and comfortable. Pick three

45NRTH Ragnarok boots also come with Cleat covers for those who are after a flat pedal performance. While not as grippy as the Shimano 800 GTX or FiveTen Trailcross, the rubber compound does a good job in keeping you on the pedals as long as you have an aggressive enough pedal to work with. OneUp Composite pedals did not have the bite but the Alloy ones worked significantly better in that task.

The Ragnarok BOAs may be the most used gear for me this winter if the weather dishes out the worst. Pairing footwear like this with the right pair of bottoms for keeping all the water out of your feet is crucial however. While you may get away with wearing shorts and long socks, I recommend fully waterproof pants like the TLD Resist, Pearl Izumi or 7Mesh Thunder Pants. If it's cold but dry, non-waterproof options like the Mons Royale could be fine.

45NRTH RAGNAROK BOA is 215 USD (on sale for 157.50 US) / 300 CAD (275 CAD at MEC)

denomerdano
Deniz Merdano

5'8"

162lbs

Playful, lively riding style

Photographer and Story Teller

Lenticular Aesthetician

www.blackbirdworks.ca

Related Stories

Trending on NSMB

Comments

metacomet
+3 Cam McRae DadStillRides jaydubmah

It is absolutely incredible to me that seemingly nobody makes a legitimately warm and waterproof winter flat pedal shoe.  One with enough insulation for when its cold cold, and still retains good pedal feel and grip for technical terrain and bike handling.  And with a full gaiter style cover over the laces and around the ankle that fits under your pants.  As it is, as far as I have found, this shoe straight up does not exist.  There are so many options of all styles and varieties that fill this need for clipless riders, but not a Single one built with a last/insole and tread specifically with flat pedals in mind.  What makes this so surprising is that for shit snow/slush/mud/ice/standing water/winter conditions, clipless pedals just make less and less sense because the cleat gets packed and frozen so easily and is a giant steel heat-sink sucking the warmth out of your foot.  There are more and more waterproof flat pedal options, but still nothing with real insulation that checks all the boxes for a winter flat pedal shoe.  Somebody make one PLEASE!  As it is, I have tried some alternatives and existing options, and they all still fall short. I am currently trying to modify a Freerider EPS to make it work for this, but seriously, how does this shoe not exist yet!?

Reply

denomerdano
0

So Shimano GF800 or fiveten trailcross gtx gore tex do not work for you? 

Are you after Ragnarok kind of insulation but more supple sole?

Reply

metacomet
0

I have the trailcross GTX, sized up so I can wear a mountaineering weight wool sock, and this is about the closest I have come to something more "winter" appropriate, at least for the transition into winter with near freezing wet and some below freezing but not way below freezing.  But its is NOT a winter shoe, and a few hours into a real winter ride my toes would literally be frozen.  I have wetted them out before, and the exposed laces are just unnecessary as they get covered in slop and freeze.  The Freerider EPS is my everyday riding shoe, and with a esker insole does an admirable job  fighting the cold for a time, but its ability to actually keep your foot dry is laughable if you take that aspect seriously.  I also have the 45nrth Wolhammer boots and will run those on flats in the coldest weather, but the rock hard and thick sole and stiff ankle cuff really does not work for technical riding.  I also picked up a pair of Vans SK8-Hi MTE 3 GoreTex shoes being that they were a safe purchase for casual wear in the winter with the hopes they would be alright on the bike, but they are not exactly a technical shoe that will really work for this application and not fall apart at the same time.

Reply

denomerdano
0

I hear your struggle. The wolfhammer shoe would be super tough to ride downhill fast in. Have you tried the giro xnetic h2o socks? They are incredible as gloves

Reply

metacomet
+1 Pete Roggeman

I have two different pairs of waterproof socks and they sort of work ok'ish, but they always feel like such a compromised half solution compared to an actual good waterproof winter shoe. I also wouldn't say they provide much more in terms of warmth compared to a good wool sock except in very specific wet conditions and not for very long exposure, and then you are still left with a completely drenched shoe and insole that needs to be dealt with as well as a drenched and muddy waterproof sock. They were at least cheap enough to try but they were not a good long term 3-6 day a week solution, and I would still freeze in the cold cold. 

I rode for years in the seemingly ubiquitous Lake MXZ 303's and those shoes served me quite well until I stopped using clipless pedals. They were warm (to a point) and very waterproof and very well made. With SO MANY people riding mountain bikes with flat pedals (I think wayyy more now than ever before) and the popularity of winter riding and fatbiking in many regions of the world, I would really expect there should be some array of comparable options that are genuinely designed specifically with flat pedals in mind.  

The persistent lack of flat pedal options is probably due to a few things, but my purely speculative and narrow ascertainment is that cyclocross is the biggest reason, coupled with historic MTB buying habits (99% of advanced riders all ride clipless pedals, and only advanced and committed riders will still be out in this cold, dark, miserable shitty weather) and cycle commuters. CX is the biggest racing scene in shittier cold weather and certainly must drive most of the demand for this type of cold and wet cycling footwear, and probaly overlaps with a majority of the customers in the second and third places as well. Looking at the "winter specific" clipless pedal demand from CX racing, manufacturers must see it as a much safer investment, and the lack of anything else in the market aimed at flat pedals reinforces the assumption of zero demand.   

I also think that part of the zero demand is a product of zero legitimate supply (Maybe not after learning about Blivet!). Buyers can't buy what doesn't exist (or that they do not know exists), and I do not count winter hiking boots, or clipless winter riding shoes with a bolted on rubber cleat insert as a legitimate good option especially in those prices. If a winter boot has a sole stiffness, thickness, sensitivity and tread pattern that you would never think about riding with in the summer, why would you want to ride with it in the winter?

Reply

skyler
+2 tmoore Timer

I heard this complaint a lot when winter riding in Calgary. But, I was always super happy riding in winter boots, which have sticky rubber because they're designed to stay soft in -30C. Sized up with Bama socks, they'd fit snug and feet would stay warm and dry. The above-the-ankle boots go stay under pant cuffs, but are flexible enough for pedaling. For $99 (https://www.rainboots.ca/cold-weather-boots), I am baffled that people $300 winter riding footwear.

Reply

metacomet
0

In flatter non-technical terrain and lower intensity, something like that may be alright, but there are other issues with those types of shoes as well.  The lifted heel and odd lugged sole would not work for me, and all the rubber means your feet will end up wet from sweat and then cold during an intense ride.  I have a similar pair of Baffin winter boots I've tried on the bike as well, but they did not offer any amount of the control I was after and suffered from the warm then sweaty then cold foot in rubber boot syndrome.

Reply

mrbrett
+1 Metacomet

Previously I was trying to make bike specific shoes like a Trailcross or Freerider EPS work, and they're alright at best in fall/spring. Currently I have moved to a $99 North Face/Columbia/??? winter boots on sale from a big-box sporting goods store work and they work just fine for me with some aggressive pedals (Daggas). I made a drill bit to create pockets in the lugs for standard aluminum/carbide studs so I don't wipe out on the ice if I need to hike, and can add chemical toe warmers if it's really nasty.

I just wish they had a little bit better laces/closures like these 45Nrth boots and I would be happy. Or, happy to just buy something similar at a bike shop with grippy rubber - ideally at approximately Freerider prices.

Reply

skyler
+1 Metacomet

Hmm, sounds like you've never ridden around Calgary.

Anyway, the bama socks are critical for heal lift, dryness and warmth. If you want to see how to stay comfortable outdoors year round, look to forestry workers who hike all day, every day.

Reply

metacomet
0

I definitely know there are ways to keep my feet warm and dry in the winter, and if that was all I was after my search would have been over a long time ago.  The missing component is a warm and dry winter boot with a good, sticky, tactile, and familiar interface with flat pedals.  The same type of good, sticky, tactile, familiar interface you would expect in a flat pedal shoe you would ride with in the summer, or when it isn't freezing cold and wet.  Its just frustrating and bewildering that there are dozens of options of every style, target temperature, and design variety from countless brands for clipless riders and (almost) none for flat pedals.  Imagine if FiveTen or Shimano or another respected flat pedal shoe company came out with a fair weather shoe with the same sole/midsole/shank/drop heel as those rain boots? Nobody would ever even consider them because they would feel and perform absolutely terrible next to all of the other fair weather options.  It would be hysterical though.

Reply

Timer
+1 Metacomet

Best one I know of is the La Sportiva Boulder Mid GTX. 

Build as an approach shoe, it has a Vibram Idrogrip sole that is actually on par with 5.10 rubber for grip. For some reason Vibram doesn’t sell this kind of sole for bike shoes. No idea why. They could own the flat pedal shoe market whenever they feel like it. 

Not a huge amount of insulation but that shouldn’t be a problem with a good pair of mountaineering socks.

Reply

metacomet
0

Those look like they have some promise, but also look a lot like a hiking shoe with the lugs and drop heel.  The TX-Canyon shoes have a good looking profile as well if only they were waterproof and insulated and had a lace cover. Lol

https://www.lasportivausa.com/tx-canyon.html

Reply

metacomet
0

Essentially, give me the upper from this shoe on a more insulated Freerider EPS lower.  Since this is a wishlist, some deeper hiking lugs at the toe and heel like on the trailcross. 

https://www.lasportivausa.com/aequilibrium-speed-gtx.html

Reply

DadStillRides
+2 Metacomet Skyler

Totally agree with your frustration in the lack of appropriate options. Like Mr. Brett, I've had better luck just finding normal winter boots that have good soles for riding. For several years I used a pair of Columbias that had amazing pedal feel, but they finally became too beat to continue repairing. Switched to a pair of keen revel 4 high polars last year. They aren't as good on the pedals, but adequate for moderate tech and keep my feet warm enough for a ~90min ride down to 0°f.

Reply

Kenny
+2 bishopsmike Metacomet

I run these:

https://www.fizik.com/rw_en/terra-nanuq-gtx-flat.html

They're plenty warm. Almost too warm for the lower mainland. 

A agree clip in shoes when snow and/or ice are likely a factor seems like a terrible plan to me. 

I also own the 510 goretex, the nanuk are much more like boots than the 510.

Reply

metacomet
0

Those look pretty good!  Not a fan of Boa laces, but those might be the closest bike-specific match to what I’ve been looking for.  How is the pedal feel/stiffness if you had to compare them to something like the trailcross gtx, or freerider eps?  Hopefully they’re not super thick and stiff as a board?

Reply

slyfink
+2 Metacomet DadStillRides

My buddies that are still riding flats for fatbiking (in the winter) are all using these: https://www.marks.com/en/pdp/helly-hansen-men-s-bivy-2-0-icefx-t-max-heat-waterproof-winter-boots-black-grey-53551875f.html?loc=plp&&colorCode=COLOUR_ASSORTED 

They've lasted several years, and they haven't really complained about lack of traction. But we're not flat-pedal riders in the summer, so don't really have anything to compare against.

Reply

DadStillRides
+1 slyfink

Slyfin, this is exactly what I'd be looking for in a winter bike boot. Will keep in a note for next time I'm in the market. Thanks for the tip.

That fizik also looks like a great shoe, but I cannot believe it would be warm enough for my needs.

Reply

Kenny
+1 Metacomet

For comparison, my trailcross GTX are also upsized, and as I tend to like more minimal MTB shoes with some flex/pedal feel, the trailcross GTX feel pretty clumsy and wooden to me. 

The nanuks have slightly better pedal feel but the upper feels more boot-like. Definitely more clunky all around versus summer riding shoes but I mean I think that's the tradeoff. 

My first ride was on wet trails but dry 5c weather with thin merino socks and my feet were sweating, it was ok but they are borderline overkill at that point. 

These are best for 0c or colder, and/or wet and/or snow. 

I think they'll be great for double duty as light weight snow boots for tobogganing and such for the few snow days a year here in the lower mainland.

They're narrow. Size up.

Reply

metacomet
0

Excellent info.  I also find the Trailcross GTX to feel pretty wooden, so hearing that these have better pedal feel and are warm is very encouraging.  I have had the Trailcross’ for like two years now and after reluctantly wearing them more and more often on and off the bike, they’re starting to break in a bit more.  Still can’t really feel the pedal very well under foot compared to my Freerider EPS, but it’s more and more manageable at this point and I’m finally wearing them without So much reservation.  I’m on the east coast, in CT, so the winters aren’t Terribly cold overall but they are super variable. We get way below freezing for a lot of the winter, but oftentimes without much or any snow. So you end up riding a lot of the same steep janky tech, only frozen and often in the dark, with water and ice and slush and every other condition imaginable. So good pedal feel and familiarity in the tech is as important as it is in every other season if you still want to ride anything more gnarly.

Reply

Isaac
+3 Metacomet DadStillRides Pete Roggeman

Have you looked into Blivet?  They're from Quebec.  I don't have the flat pedal ones (yet) but everything else from them seems to be well thought out and made.  https://blivetsports.com/collections/bottes-1/products/quilo-flt-boots-gen-2?variant=40165217173638

Reply

metacomet
+2 Isaac L. DadStillRides

Had never heard of them or come across their stuff before, so thank you for sharing!  Their flat pedal winter boots look like a legit option that would work in the dead of winter where I am. Might give these a shot.  

I think NSMB could own the non-existent winter flat pedal shoe review space if they got ahold of some of these options to baseline and compare.  I’m sure there’s more than a few people that would find that extremely useful.

Reply

andrewbikeguide
0

Blivet Quilo Flat - light, grippy and warm.

Reply

LoamtoHome
+1 Deniz Merdano

those would be great for the dig/ride days...

Reply

denomerdano
0

Yes! Can confirm, during the riding photos, I stood in streams and moved drainage rocks!

Reply

slyfink
0

hmmm. interesting. I might be looking to replace my 10 (or is that 12 or 14 year old) Specialized Defrosters soon. I'll start wearing them in the shoulder season once it reaches about +5°C. They have just enough insulation to remain comfortable with normal wool socks down to about -8°C. Below that, I use my heated socks (Lenz) down to -15. Below that, I'll throw on a neoprene shoe covers and I'm good till -20. Below that, it's not fun anymore, so I'll just stay home. for me, this is like a layering system for jackets. Given they get most of their use in the winter, they tend to last a loooong time, and I really like their versatility, so I have found them a good value in the end. My main gripe with them is the stack height, and - most importantly - not being able to get the cleat far enough back.

so these have piqued my interest, but a few questions remain: how far back can the cleat go (you said to the arch of your foot... as in half way back?), and what kind of insulation is there? fleece? thinsulate? primaloft? none?

Reply

denomerdano
+1 slyfink

I guess i should have been more clear on that. Normally I run my cleats as far back as the shoe will allow.

This does make finding the pedal slightly more difficult in most situations, considering the use-case scenario fpr these boots, I anticipated some snow and mud build up that would male it even harder to clip in, thus I placed my cleats a cm more forward than I normally would. They go back plenty if you want them to.

Reply

slyfink
0

that's good info, thanks! any word on insulation?

Reply

cam@nsmb.com
0

I had some defrosters from back when I was clipping in. They were excellent. I just checked and unfortunately they no longer make them. They were expensive as well - 320 CAD, but well worth it if you can find some. 

Here's my review.

Reply

slyfink
0

fwiw, I've seen advertisements for these on Euro-based sites, and have been curious about them: https://cronoteam.com/en/winter-cw1e/ they seem to hit all the design elements I like, but it's hard to find a review of them though... (hint hint...)

Reply

pete@nsmb.com
+1 slyfink

I've reached out to them. Had heard of them before but haven't had any contact. We'll see if they reply. Another brand worth checking out is Northwave - they have an extensive offering of winter flat and clipless shoes, but they switch Canadian distributors every few years so it's hard to track them down. They are, however, great shoes (and I think they may be the ones manufacturing Crono's shoes).

Reply

denomerdano
0

395Gr!!! That's some light winter boot. Also liking the extra information they have on the site about saddle height change and stiffness index.

Reply

Please log in to leave a comment.